
The Common Application essay is one of the most critical components of a college application. It allows students to showcase their personality, experiences, and perspectives beyond grades and test scores. A well-written essay can distinguish between standing out in a competitive pool or blending into the background. However, not all essays achieve their intended impact. Some captivate admissions officers, leaving a lasting impression, while others fail to resonate. Let’s explore what makes a Common App essay shine and highlight common pitfalls that can weaken an otherwise promising application. We will look at common app essay examples.
The Good: What Makes a Strong Common App Essay?
A successful Common App essay effectively captures the applicant’s voice tells a compelling story and demonstrates depth and introspection. Here are the essential elements of a standout common app essay examples :
1. Authenticity and Personal Voice
Example: A student shares their struggle with public speaking and how joining a debate club helped them overcome their fear, gradually gaining confidence and leadership skills.
Why It Works: Admissions officers appreciate genuine stories that reveal a student’s true character rather than what they think colleges want to hear. Authenticity resonates and makes the essay feel personal and engaging.
2. Compelling Storytelling
Example: A student narrates their experience volunteering at a refugee camp, describing a specific moment when they connected with a young child and how it shifted their worldview on privilege and empathy.
Why It Works: A strong narrative with vivid details and a clear arc makes the essay immersive and memorable. Readers should feel like they are experiencing the story firsthand.
3. Clear Focus and Theme
Example: Instead of listing multiple achievements, students focus on a single impactful experience—like building a robot from scratch with limited resources—highlighting their creativity and perseverance.
Why It Works: A well-structured essay centered around a clear theme prevents confusion and maintains the reader’s engagement. Less is often more when it comes to storytelling.
4. Reflection and Personal Growth
Example: A student writes about failing to make the varsity soccer team and how that experience, instead of discouraging them, taught them the importance of resilience and self-improvement.
Why It Works: Colleges value self-awareness and maturity. Essays emphasizing personal growth demonstrate students’ ability to learn from experiences and evolve.
5. A Creative Approach
Example: Students craft their essays as conversations between their present and future selves, discussing fears, aspirations, and lessons learned.
Why It Works: A unique and creative structure can make an essay stand out without sacrificing depth and clarity. It demonstrates originality while keeping the reader engaged.
Read on What is a common app essay?
Good Common App Essay Example
Topic: Overcoming Failure and Personal Growth
“The first time I stepped onto the soccer field, I was the worst player on the team. I tripped over the ball, missed passes, and spent more time apologizing than actually playing. But I kept coming back. I watched game footage, trained in the early mornings, and sought advice from my coach. A year later, I became the team captain. This experience taught me that failure isn’t an end—it’s a beginning. It shaped how I approach challenges, from academics to leadership roles. Now, when I face difficulties, I don’t shrink back—I step forward.”
Why It Works:
-
Shows personal growth and resilience
-
Uses a compelling, specific story
-
Reflects on lessons learned and future application
-
Engages the reader with a strong narrative
The Worst: Common Mistakes That Weaken a Common App Essay
Some essays fail to make an impact due to common pitfalls. Here are common app essay examples mistakes to avoid:
1. Clichéd Topics Without a Unique Angle
Example: Writing about scoring the winning goal in a soccer match without adding personal insight or depth.
Why It Fails: Overused topics without a fresh perspective can feel generic and unimpressive. If you choose a common theme, ensure you bring a unique angle.
2. Excessive Bragging or Resume Listing
Example: An essay that reads like a resume, listing all achievements without a meaningful narrative or personal insight.
Why It Fails: Admissions officers want to see personality, not just accomplishments. They’re looking for depth and storytelling rather than a list of accolades.
3. Overly Formal or Unnatural Tone
Example: Writing in an overly academic or robotic style instead of being conversational and personal.
Why It Fails: The essay should reflect the student’s natural voice. Forced formality can make the writing feel detached and impersonal.
4. Lack of Reflection
Example: A student describes a volunteer experience but doesn’t explain how it changed them or influenced their perspective.
Why It Fails: Without reflection, the essay lacks depth. The most impactful essays show how an experience shaped the applicant’s growth and outlook.
5. Trying Too Hard to Be Unique
Example: Writing an essay entirely in haikus or an overly abstract concept that confuses rather than engages.
Why It Fails: While creativity is valuable, the essay needs substance and clarity. If the format distracts from the message, it weakens the impact.
6. Poor Structure and Rambling
Example: An essay that jumps from one idea to another without a clear progression.
Why It Fails: Disorganized essays are hard to follow and can confuse admissions officers. A logical flow ensures clarity and coherence.
Read on Tips for Writing Common App Essay
Bad Common App Essay Example
Topic: My Summer Vacation
“Last summer, my family and I went to Italy. We visited the Colosseum, ate a lot of pasta, and walked around Rome. The weather was great, and I enjoyed seeing the historical sites. I also took a lot of pictures. Overall, it was a fun trip, and I learned a little bit about Italian culture.”
Why It Fails:
-
Generic and unoriginal (many students write about travel)
-
No personal reflection or deeper meaning
-
It reads more like a diary entry than an essay
-
Doesn’t tell us anything meaningful about the applicant
Final Thoughts
The Common App essay allows you to stand out beyond grades and test scores. A well-crafted essay should be authentic, engaging, and reflective. By avoiding common pitfalls and focusing on compelling storytelling, you can significantly enhance your chances of making a lasting impression.
Need Help With Your Common App Essay?
If you’re struggling to write the perfect essay, consider working with an expert to refine your ideas and strengthen your writing. A strong college essay can make all the difference!
Start writing today and tell your story in a way that admissions officers won’t forget.